Investment Perspectives
Credit Where Credit's Due - The Role of Real Estate Credit
Real Assets
April 1, 2022 8 Minute Read Time
Real estate debt is playing an increasingly important role in real assets portfolios, say CBRE Investment Management’s Isabelle Brennan, Todd Sammann, Emma Huepfl and Dominic Smith
Q: How would you describe investor appetite for real estate credit today?
Isabelle Brennan: We have seen an explosion in interest for private credit more broadly over the past few years and, within that, real estate credit has an important role to play. It all started with interest in mezzanine as banks retrenched post-GFC, but over the past few years the focus has moved more towards first-lien senior lending.We have seen capital flowing in all directions, from EMEA to the US and vice versa and from Asia-Pacific into both of those geographies. Many of those investors already have active real estate equity portfolios and so it has been a pretty easy transition to the credit side. We have seen strong appetite from insurance companies, sovereign wealth funds and particularly pension plans.
Q: What are those investors looking for from real estate credit, in terms of their overall portfolio construction?
IB: Real estate credit is one of those asset classes that can serve a number of different purposes. It offers bond-like characteristics, which means it works as a fixed income substitute. But it also has real asset security, so it can look a lot like real estate equity. We see allocations from both buckets.Real estate credit offers stable, predictable income streams and significant downside protection. It offers diversification benefits and is also a very efficient way to deploy capital because the transaction costs are much lower than for equity. Overall, it can really improve an investor’s risk-adjusted returns because it tends to reduce volatility in the portfolio.
The benefit of real estate credit has been highlighted for multi-asset credit investors through the pandemic. Corporates have failed but even when the real estate assets that back our loans have seen rent collections fall, we have experienced no missed interest payments or distributions to our investors. That is because we have early intervention mechanisms in place that bring borrowers to the table to work out the most effective way of protecting those positions. Real estate has really proved its worth to credit investors over the past 18 months.
Todd Sammann: The catalyst to much of the interest we’ve seen results from cap-rate compression, which has made it difficult for equity fund managers to produce current return. In that context, credit’s combination of contractual current yield and low volatility have proven to be attractive.
I would add that newer sectors tend to be funded by equity. The credit markets then step in later when a track record has been established. What that means is that if a yield gap has normalized on the equity side, a premium may still be possible on the credit side. If an investor feels they have missed the boat with an emerging sector, they may have a second chance with credit.
Q: Which sectors are now the most appealing?
TS: In the US, multifamily has benefited from strong demand driven by a growing economy and home affordability issues. At the same time, it offers an inflation hedge and low correlation to equities. Under the Biden administration, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have been mandated to allocate half their origination activity to the affordable housing sector. That’s left a void in the market for market-rate assets and created interesting opportunities for private lenders.Meanwhile, the office sector has taken a beating during the pandemic and many lenders appear to have red-lined the sector entirely. But while some form of work from home is clearly here to stay, workplaces will also have an important role to play going forward. The challenge, and the opportunity, is to identify the combination of office attributes that will attract the lion’s share of tenant demand and investor capital going forward. Meanwhile, a lack of competition means we can generate greater return through higher coupons and drive more robust loan structures than in other sectors.
EH: We see similar themes in Europe. There is a lot of competition in logistics and residential, which can make those sectors unattractive from a returns point of view, particularly when competing with bank capital which tends to lead on pricing. The way we address that is to underwrite assets at an earlier stage of maturity, by funding development, lease-up or capex or, particularly in residential, by bridging sale once a development facility has expired.
In the office space, where an equity case can be challenging and the outlook is very uncertain, credit is an interesting way for investors to maintain sectoral exposure on a lower-risk basis, while getting paid very well for doing so. With credit, you have those different lines of defense: the asset itself, and then the loan structure around that. Even in challenged sectors, you can create highly defensive positions and deliver attractive returns.
Q: What role does data play in real estate credit?
DS: There is an accepted truth that there is no data in real estate debt, but we don’t think that is right. Data is often in hard-to-reach places, but there is a huge amount out there which can move real estate credit closer to the equity side than people generally believe. For example, we have built a tool that will bring together numerous metrics from the perspective of risk, return and opportunity.That tool helps investors understand downside forecasts, tenant default risk, returns versus fixed income, how much refinancing is coming due and what the competitive landscape is like, for example. It is up to individual investors to then decide if protecting downside risk is their priority, or returns, or simply getting money out of the door. That helps them decide which sectors and markets to pursue. It isn’t an easy undertaking; but we are privileged to have access to vast amounts of data as part of the broader real estate platform.
Q: How has the role of ESG in real estate credit evolved?
EH: Investors are much more discerning and exclude assets and borrowers with poor sustainability credentials. Borrowers, meanwhile, are asking us to collaborate to evolve their ESG policies. Credit may be a step removed from the asset, but there is no reason it can’t positively influence outcomes.TS: We take sustainability very seriously and screen each of our investments aggressively against carbon footprint, air and water quality and flood risk, for example. The last thing we want to do is make a loan against an asset that might be underwater or functionally obsolete when the loan matures.
DS: From a macro perspective, we are seeing a huge funding gap for refurbishing assets. Upwards of 75 percent of stock in Europe doesn’t meet energy efficiency standards consistent with net-zero targets. Those buildings can’t just be torn down, because of all the embedded carbon; they need to be retrofitted up to standard.
Real estate is responsible for around 40 percent of energy emissions in the EU, so we have to get this right. Retrofitting is a significant one-off event; it can’t be financed through maintenance budgets and so there is a huge need for lenders to get involved. At the same time, UK banks stepped right back from development, particularly commercial development, in the wake of the financial crisis. New EU banking regulation will cause a funding gap there. Non-bank lenders really need to step up for the good of the industry and the good of the planet.
Q: What changes have you noted in terms of the way debt is being structured?
TS: Structure is a reflection of competitive dynamics and is one of a number of levers lenders use when competing for business. In a market that is oversupplied with capital relative to demand, you tend to see spread compression first, and then a weakening in structure.There has been a proliferation of debt funds in the US over the past five years. Around 80 percent of allocated capital has gone to value-add and opportunistic strategies. The excess supply of capital in those segments triggered spread compression of as much as 300bps to 400bps. Structure then increasingly became a point of negotiation. In the core-plus segment, however, the supply/demand balance is far heathier. We haven’t seen nearly as much spread compression or any meaningful weakening in structure there.
Q: So, what does the future hold for this asset class?
TS: I expect to see real estate credit embraced as a truly institutional asset class. That will require transparency, however. The first step on that journey will be to establish a series of debt fund indices to facilitate analysis of relative performance to create proper accountability. Second, while we’ve seen a proliferation of debt funds over the past five years, I expect the next five will bring consolidation. My sense is that capital will flow to larger managers with demonstrable information and sourcing advantage, as well as investing and operational expertise.Contacts
The Real Assets Reality
-
Market Research
Chart of the Week
Chart of the Week details economic data and commentary from our Research and Investment teams on the market and investment trends of the day.
-
Investment Perspectives
CBRE IM Answers Your Tough Questions
CBRE IM Answers Your Tough Questions is a series of webcasts about commercial real estate investment in which our regional and sector CIOs take live questions from the audience.
-
Market Research
Quality and Modernity Deliver for U.S. Logistics
The U.S. logistics market has broadly normalized after extraordinary conditions during the Covid-19 pandemic.
-
Market Research
Infrastructure Quarterly: Q1 2024
The resilience of infrastructure amid economic uncertainty presents a compelling investment case. Read more in the latest installment of the Infrastructure Quarterly.
-
Market Research
Infrastructure Quarterly
The resilience of infrastructure in an economic downturn presents a compelling investment case: Infrastructure Quarterly dives into the state of the market.
-
Investment Perspectives
Infra-AI: The Quiet Boom in Listed Infrastructure for Artificial Intelligence
The surge in investor focus on Generative AI (Gen AI) overlooks listed infrastructure, where companies enable growth in data consumption, data centers and the clean power that is already supporting the technology.
-
Investment Perspectives
Global Next-Generation Infrastructure: A Core Plus Strategy for the Mid-Market
Essential services like water, electricity & connectivity drive infrastructure's strength. Global 2.0 strategies prioritize downside protection & sectors like digital & renewables for long-term impact. Navigate volatility with flexibility & global reach in this unique asset class.
-
Enhanced Return Opportunities | Investment Perspectives
Unlocking Potential Value Through Enhanced Return Real Estate
Enhanced return real estate strategies include value-add and opportunistic investments, that help develop, grow and transition properties to generate strong cash flow.
-
Investment Perspectives
Global Cyclical Opportunity
Real estate correction presents unique opportunities. Embrace the paradigm shift with active management, global reach, and sector-specific strategies to capture cyclical value.
-
Investment Perspectives
The Bright Future for Secondaries
The secondaries market has the potential to provide investors with a number of advantages amid the challenges of the current market.
-
Investment Perspectives
The Kick-off: Listed Real Assets for Investors
Explore our 2024 outlook on real assets, reviewing performance history, relative valuations, and potential return opportunities in real estate and infrastructure.
-
Investment Perspectives
Listed Outlook Commentary Q4 2023
2024 paints a compelling picture for listed real estate & infrastructure, potentializing top returns. Dive into our outlook: REIT & infra analysis, key sector dynamics, and active management's alpha potential.
-
Investment Perspectives
Labor Proximity is a Major Driver of Logistics Occupiers’ Location Strategy
Logistics occupiers have a growing number of considerations to weigh-up when assessing the optimal location for new assets.
-
Investment Perspectives
Europe’s Retail Renaissance
Europe retail reboots: location, adaptation, & integrated models unlock value. Dive into the post-pandemic boom.
-
Investment Perspectives
The Starting Line: Listed Infrastructure ready to run
Listed infrastructure underperformed in 2023, setting the stage for a potential bull run reminiscent of 2003-2007. We analyze catalysts, earnings, valuations, and positioning for future outperformance.
-
Investment Perspectives
It's Morning for Listed Real Estate
We’re optimistic for the potential for listed real estate performance in 2024. After nearly two years of negative returns and a significant dislocation from private market values, the REIT asset class is well positioned for investors, in our view.
-
Market Research
Infrastructure Quarterly: Q4 2023
In this Q4 edition of Infrastructure Quarterly, we highlight the rising investment requirements to reinforce power grids and cope with double digit demand growth by 2030.
-
Investment Perspectives
Listed Real Assets are Core
Unveil the 2024 listed market outlook in our webcast recording. Check out our insights, unlock value, & discover optimal allocation strategies.
-
Investment Perspectives
The Case for Life Sciences
Life sciences real estate is immune to the work from home factor and benefits from strong fundamentals and long-term structural drivers, making it a preferred office subsector strategy.
-
Why Core Real Estate?
Staying the course with Core Real Estate
Core real estate continues to be a reliable asset class, offering investors strong current income, portfolio diversification and protection against inflation and cyclical change.
-
Investment Perspectives
The Future of Medical Office: A Resilient Investment in Healthcare's Future
Medical office sector shows resilience with high-income returns and low volatility, being unaffected by economic downturns and remote work trends.
-
Market Research
Mid-Market Infrastructure: Riding the downturn
The mid-market infrastructure sector is rich with long-term opportunities across next generation sustainable industries with the potential for enhanced returns.
-
Investment Perspectives
High Grade: The opportunity to enhance MLP allocations with listed infrastructure
Long-standing investors in midstream energy have been rewarded for their patience over the last several years, as the asset class has been amongst the strongest performers in listed real assets with the recovery from Covid.
-
Market Research
European Logistics: Adjusting to the new normal
The European logistics sector has seen dramatic change over the past decade with demand for space surging, in particular in response to pandemic-changed behaviors.